籬廬 magalia / Cicero

TRIAL · 诉讼

Sestius · public violence塞斯提乌斯 · 暴力案

56 BCE公元前56年Defence advocate辩护人Acquittal reported据报开释

Accused: 被告:P. Sestius塞斯提乌斯

Next trial →下一案 →

How to assess this result如何评估此结果 magalia’s description本站描述

A reported unanimous acquittal. Cicero presents consensus as politically valuable and his own service as exemplary. The speech supplies a rationale for protective force; the letter does not say the jurors adopted it.据报全票开释。西塞罗称一致具有政治价值,又称自己尽力报恩。演说提出防护性武力的理由;信未说陪审者采纳了它。

Causa names the case or the cause; the word alone establishes no binding or informal precedent. Andrew M. Riggsby reads the letter as Cicero presenting the acquittal as an informal precedent (“Did the Romans Believe in Their Verdicts?”, Rhetorica 15 (1997) 239); the jurors’ own reasons are not recorded.causa 指案件或事业,单凭此词不能确立正式或非正式判例。Andrew M. Riggsby 认为西塞罗在信中把此次开释视为一项非正式判例(“Did the Romans Believe in Their Verdicts?”,Rhetorica 15,1997年,第239页);陪审者自己的理由未见记载。

What this establishes about precedent判例问题:证据能说明什么

No adopted general rule established by the assembled evidence.现有证据未能确立法庭采纳了一般规则。

Riggsby’s reading, checked against the letterRiggsby 的解读与原信对照

Andrew M. Riggsby, “Did the Romans Believe in Their Verdicts?”, Rhetorica 15 (1997) 235–251, at 239, quotes this letter and reads Cicero as taking the acquittal to vindicate a principle argued in Pro Sestio: that Sestius’ patriotic motive justified his violence. On that reading the letter concerns an informal precedent, rather than Cicero’s performance or Sestius’ character.Andrew M. Riggsby,“Did the Romans Believe in Their Verdicts?”,Rhetorica 15(1997),235—251,第239页,引用此信,认为西塞罗视此次开释为对《为塞斯提乌斯辩护》所立原则的认可,即塞斯提乌斯出于爱国动机,其暴力因而正当。按此解读,信所论是一项非正式判例,与西塞罗的辩护表现及塞斯提乌斯的品格无关。

  • Confirmed: causa and unanimity occur in the letter. The emphasis on public agreement is explicit.已核实:信中有 causa 及全票开释,公共一致确为明言。
  • Qualified: the paragraph also discusses Cicero’s gratitude, performance and attack on Vatinius. It is too strong to exclude those concerns from the whole passage.须限定:同段亦谈报恩、辩护表现及攻击瓦提尼乌斯,不能把这些关切排除在整段之外。
  • Unproved: the jurors accepted a doctrine permitting patriotic violence, or created an informal precedent. No source records the jurors’ reasons.未获证实:陪审者接受爱国暴力正当性的原则,或创设非正式判例;史料未载陪审者的理由。
  • Date: Riggsby’s 14 March matches Shackleton Bailey’s text, a. d. ii Id. Mart.; Purser’s text, printed here, reads a. d. v Idus Martias, 11 March.日期:Riggsby 所引3月14日与 Shackleton Bailey 本 a. d. ii Id. Mart. 相合;此处所印 Purser 本作 a. d. v Idus Martias,即3月11日。

Evidence and its surroundings证据及其上下文

Sestius: unanimity, gratitude and the attack on Vatinius塞斯提乌斯:全票、报恩与攻击瓦提尼乌斯

Cicero, Q. fr. 2.4.1

Before the selection选段之前

This is the opening paragraph of the letter: there is no preceding paragraph within it. For the earlier accusation, compare Q. fr. 2.3.5 separately. Cicero writes to his brother after defending a political ally involved in his recall from exile.这是该信首段,信内没有前一段。此前指控另见 Q. fr. 2.3.5,不能当成本信连续上文。西塞罗在为参与促成自己回归的政治盟友辩护后致信弟弟。

Read the preceding original context阅读前文原文 (0)
The passage opens the letter; nothing precedes it.此段为信首,前无上文。

Selected original passage所选原文

urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi058.perseus-lat1:2.4.1
2.4.1Sestius noster absolutus est a. d. v Idus Martias et, quod vehementer interfuit rei publicae nullam videri in eius modi causa dissensionem esse, omnibus sententiis absolutus est. illud quod tibi curae saepe esse intellexeram ne cui iniquo relinqueremus vituperandi locum qui nos ingratos esse diceret nisi illius perversitatem quibusdam in rebus quam humanissime ferremus, scito hoc nos in eo iudicio consecutos esse ut omnium gratissimi iudicaremur ; nam defendendo moroso homini cumulatissime satis fecimus et, id quod ille maxime cupiebat, Vatinium a quo palam oppugnabatur arbitratu nostro concidimus dis hominibusque plaudentibus. quin etiam Paulus noster, cum testis productus esset in Sestium, confirmavit se nomen Vatini delaturum si Macer Licinius cunctaretur, et Macer ab Sesti subselliis surrexit ac se illi non defuturum adfirmavit. quid quaeris? homo petulans et audax ⟦Vatinius⟧ valde perturbatus debilitatusque discessit.
Source unit XML · 来源单元

Editorial summary编辑摘要

Cicero reports a unanimous acquittal and stresses how important the appearance of agreement was for the commonwealth in a case of this kind. The same paragraph then boasts of satisfying a difficult client and defeating Vatinius in cross-examination.西塞罗报告全票开释,强调共和国需要在此类案件中呈现一致。同一段随即夸说自己使难以应付的当事人满意,并在诘问中击败瓦提尼乌斯。

After the selection选段之后

The letter moves from public unanimity to Cicero’s own obligations and performance, then in 2.4.2 to Quintus’ education, building work and Tullia’s engagement. Read with this continuation, the political news sits among Cicero’s personal and family concerns.信先论公共一致,继而谈西塞罗自己的义务与表现,2.4.2 又转入侄儿教育、营建与图利娅婚约。连同后文读,此信的政治消息与私事、家事并列。

Read the following original context阅读后文原文 (1)
urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi058.perseus-lat1:2.4.2
2.4.2Quintus ⟦filius⟧ tuus, puer optimus, eruditur egregie. hoc nunc magis animum adverto quod Tyrannio docet apud me. domus utriusque nostrum aedificatur strenue. redemptori tuo dimidium pecuniae curavi. spero nos ante hiemem contubernalis fore. de nostra Tullia tui me hercule amantissima spero cum Crassipede nos confecisse. dies erant duo qui post is Latinas habentur religiosi ; †cetero confectum erat Latiar erat†.
Source unit XML · 来源单元

The verdict and its unanimity are a participant’s report; the jurors’ reasons, and whether they adopted a general legal principle, are not recorded. The editions differ on the day, counted inclusively back from the Ides (15 March): Purser’s text, printed here, reads a. d. v Idus Martias, 11 March; Shackleton Bailey’s (Cicero: Epistulae ad Quintum fratrem et M. Brutum, Cambridge 1980) reads a. d. ii Id. Mart., 14 March, and records v in one manuscript.判决及全票出自参与者报告,未载陪审者的理由,也未载其是否采纳一般法律原则。日期各版不同(自3月15日 Idus 倒数,首尾皆计):此处所印 Purser 本作 a. d. v Idus Martias,即3月11日;Shackleton Bailey 本(Cicero: Epistulae ad Quintum fratrem et M. Brutum,剑桥,1980年)作 a. d. ii Id. Mart.,即3月14日,并记一抄本作 v。

Edition, reuse and extraction版本、复用与提取

Perseus Digital Library, Tufts University; Cicero. Ciceronis, M. Tullius. Epistulae, Vol. III. Purser, Louis Claude, editor. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1901.

Perseus repository · 语料库 · CC BY-SA 4.0

Whitespace normalized; notes separated; deletions ⟦ ⟧ and additions/supplements ⟨ ⟩ marked; gaps explicit; no ancient wording supplied.

SHA-256 30692e2117b3981099e86ea8aceeb5c04a09b6b3c36f2dbd91e8061b8b1fb77b

machine-assisted editorial synthesis; exact source extraction checked; independent scholarly review pending

The accusations before the acquittal开释以前的指控

Cicero, Q. fr. 2.3.5

Before the selection选段之前

The preceding paragraph concerns Clodius’ mobilization and Pompey’s position. Against this account of political pressure, Cicero records formal accusations and his own response.前段涉及克洛狄乌斯的动员与庞培处境;在政治压力的叙述中,西塞罗记下正式指控及自己的回应。

Read the preceding original context阅读前文原文 (1)
urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi058.perseus-lat1:2.3.4
2.3.4itaque magnae mihi res iam moveri videbantur. nam Pompeius haec intellegit nobiscumque communicat, insidias vitae suae fieri, C. Catonem a Crasso sustentari, Clodio pecuniam suppeditari, utrumque et ab eo et a Curione, Bibulo, ceterisque suis obtrectatoribus confirmari; vehementer esse providendum ne opprimatur contionario illo populo a se prope alienato, nobilitate inimica, non aequo senatu, iuventute improba. itaque se comparat, homines ex agris accersit operas autem suas Clodius confirmat ; manus ad Quirinalia paratur. in eo multo sumus superiores ipsius copiis ; sed magna manus ex Piceno et Gallia exspectatur, ut etiam Catonis rogationibus de Milone et Lentulo resistamus.
Source unit XML · 来源单元

Selected original passage所选原文

urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi058.perseus-lat1:2.3.5
2.3.5A. d. iiii Idus Febr. Sestius ab indice Cn. Nerio Pupinia de ambitu est postulatus et eodem die a quodam P. Tullio de vi. is erat aeger. domum, ut debuimus, ad eum statim venimus eique nos totos tradidimus idque fecimus praeter hominum opinionem qui nos ei iure suscensere putabant, at humanissimi gratissimique et ipsi et omnibus videremur, taque faciemus. sed idem Nerius index edidit ad allegatos Cn. Lentulum vatiam et C. Cornelium †ista ei†. eodem die senatus consultum factum est ut sodalitates decuriatique discederent lexque de iis ferretur, ut qui non discessissent ea poena quae est de vi tenerentur.
Source unit XML · 来源单元

Editorial summary编辑摘要

The letter distinguishes an ambitus accusation from a vis accusation on the same day; Cicero reports visiting the sick Sestius and committing himself to his support.信区分同日的贿选指控与暴力指控;西塞罗称自己探望患病的塞斯提乌斯并承诺相助。

After the selection选段之后

The following paragraph describes Cicero using his defence of Bestia to praise the wounded Sestius. Advocacy for one man can prepare the audience for another man’s trial.下段描述西塞罗借为贝斯提亚辩护赞颂负伤的塞斯提乌斯。替一人辩护,也可能为另一人的案件预备听众。

Read the following original context阅读后文原文 (1)
urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi058.perseus-lat1:2.3.6
2.3.6A. d. iii Idus Febr. dixi pro Bestia de ambitu apud praetorem Cn. Domitium in foro medio maximo conventu incidique in eum locum in dicendo, cum Sestius multis in templo Castoris vulneribus acceptis subsidio Bestiae servatus esset. hic προῳκονομησάμην quiddam εὐκαίρωσ de iis quae in Sestium adparabantur crimina, et eum ornavi veris laudibus magno adsensu omnium. res homini fuit vehementer grata. quae tibi eo scribo, quod me de retinenda Sesti gratia litteris saepe monuisti.
Source unit XML · 来源单元

Neither accusation has a verdict in this letter; the acquittal reported in Q. fr. 2.4.1 was on the charge of vis. The text is corrupt at †ista ei†.此信未载两项指控的判决;Q. fr. 2.4.1 所报开释属暴力一案。†ista ei† 一处文本有讹。

Edition, reuse and extraction版本、复用与提取

Perseus Digital Library, Tufts University; Cicero. Ciceronis, M. Tullius. Epistulae, Vol. III. Purser, Louis Claude, editor. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1901.

Perseus repository · 语料库 · CC BY-SA 4.0

Whitespace normalized; notes separated; deletions ⟦ ⟧ and additions/supplements ⟨ ⟩ marked; gaps explicit; no ancient wording supplied.

SHA-256 30692e2117b3981099e86ea8aceeb5c04a09b6b3c36f2dbd91e8061b8b1fb77b

machine-assisted editorial synthesis; exact source extraction checked; independent scholarly review pending

When courts fail: the defence’s argument for armed protection法庭失效时:为武装自卫所作的辩论

Cicero, Pro Sestio 86–92

Before the selection选段之前

These paragraphs follow the account of attacks on Sestius. Cicero must explain why a defendant accused of vis assembled armed protection, while the prosecutor apparently praised Milo’s conduct.这些段落承接塞斯提乌斯遭袭叙述。被告既被控暴力,西塞罗便须解释其为何组织武装护卫,并利用控方似曾赞许米洛的立场。

Read the preceding original context阅读前文原文 (1)
urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi022.perseus-lat2:85
85captum erat forum anno superiore, aede Castoris tamquam arce aliqua ⟨a⟩ fugitivis occupata: silebatur. omnia hominum cum egestate tum audacia perditorum clamore, concursu, vi, manu gerebantur: perferebatis. magistratus templis pellebantur, alii omnino aditu ac foro prohibebantur: nemo resistebat. gladiatores ex praetoris comitatu comprensi, in senatum introducti, confessi, in vincla coniecti a Milone, emissi a Serrano: mentio nulla. forum corporibus civium Romanorum constratum caede nocturna: non modo nulla nova quaestio, sed etiam vetera iudicia sublata. tribunum plebis plus viginti vulneribus acceptis iacentem moribundumque vidistis: alterius tribuni plebis divini hominis—dicam enim quod sentio et quod mecum sentiunt omnes—divini, insigni quadam, inaudita, nova magnitudine animi, gravitate, fide praediti, domus est oppugnata ferro, facibus, exercitu Clodiano.
Edition notes (7)版本注记(7)
  • anno sup. secl. Koch
  • aliquando Schlenger (Liv. iii. 15. 5)
  • templis templo Pluygers
  • conprensi PG: comprehensi B edd.
  • divini secl. Momms.: sed cf. cogitaris, Vat. § 19.
  • omnes divina ed. R.: omnes divini viri Jacob: omnes boni viri coni. Halm (omnes boni k): omnes honesti viri Maehly
  • Alterum divini (l. 8) om. k, in parenth. inclusit Hertz, quod sentio ... divini, — insigni etc.
Source unit XML · 来源单元

Selected original passage所选原文

urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi022.perseus-lat2:86
86et tu hoc loco laudas Milonem et iure laudas. quem enim umquam virum tam immortali virtute vidimus? qui nullo praemio proposito praeter hoc, quod iam contritum et contemptum putatur, iudicium bonorum, omnia pericula, summos labores, gravissimas contentiones inimicitiasque suscepit, qui mihi unus ex omnibus civibus videtur re docuisse, non verbis, et quid oporteret a praestantibus viris in re publica fieri et quid necesse esset: oportere hominum audacium, eversorum rei publicae, sceleri legibus et iudiciis resistere; si leges non valerent, iudicia non essent, si res publica vi consensuque audacium armis oppressa teneretur, praesidio et copiis defendi vitam et libertatem necesse esse. hoc sentire prudentiae est, facere fortitudinis; et sentire vero et facere perfectae cumulataeque virtutis.
Edition notes (3)版本注记(3)
  • virtute laude praeditum k
  • et quid Car. Steph.: sed quid codd. (quid Hk)
  • (civium) vitam K. Busche
Source unit XML · 来源单元
urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi022.perseus-lat2:87
87adiit ad rem publicam tribunus plebis Milo—de cuius laude plura dicam, non quo aut ipse haec dici quam existimari malit aut ego hunc laudis fructum praesenti libenter impertiam, praesertim cum verbis consequi non possim, sed quod existimo, si Milonis causam accusatoris voce conlaudatam probaro, vos in hoc crimine parem Sesti causam existimaturos: adiit igitur T. Annius ad causam rei publicae sic ut civem patriae reciperare vellet ereptum. simplex causa, constans ratio, plena consensionis omnium, plena concordiae. conlegas adiutores habebat; consulis alterius summum studium, alterius animus paene placatus, de praetoribus unus alienus, senatus incredibilis voluntas, equitum Romanorum animi ad causam excitati, erecta Italia. duo soli erant empti ad impediendum; qui si homines despecti et contempti tantam rem sustinere non potuissent, se causam quam susceperat nullo labore peracturum videbat. agebat auctoritate, agebat consilio, agebat per summum ordinem, agebat exemplo bonorum ac fortium civium: quid re publica, quid se dignum esset, quis ipse esset, quid sperare, quid maioribus suis reddere deberet, diligentissime cogitabat.
Edition notes (3)版本注记(3)
  • trib. pleb. secl. Bake
  • ereptum Pantagathus: e rep. ereptum Hertz: e re .p. tum P rell.
  • Conl. adiut. hab. post Italia l. 9) transf. Paul
Source unit XML · 来源单元
urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi022.perseus-lat2:88
88huic gravitati hominis videbat ille gladiator se, si moribus ageret, parem esse non posse; ad ferrum, faces, ad cotidianam caedem, incendia, rapinas se cum exercitu suo contulit; domum oppugnare, itineribus occurrere, vi lacessere et terrere coepit. non movit hominem summa gravitate summaque constantia; sed quamquam dolor animi, innata libertas, prompta excellensque virtus fortissimum virum hortabatur vi vim, oblatam praesertim saepius, ut frangeret et refutaret, tanta moderatio fuit hominis, tantum consilium, ut contineret dolorem neque eadem se re ulcisceretur qua esset lacessitus, sed illum tot iam in funeribus rei publicae exsultantem ac tripudiantem legum, si posset, laqueis constringeret.
Edition notes (2)版本注记(2)
  • ad ferrum faces s. l. P2: ad ferrum, ad faces edd. vett.
  • vi vim oblatam, praes. saepius edd.
Source unit XML · 来源单元
urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi022.perseus-lat2:89
89descendit ad accusandum. quis umquam tam proprie rei publicae causa, nullis inimicitiis, nullis praemiis, nulla hominum postulatione aut etiam opinione id eum umquam esse facturum? fracti erant animi hominis; hoc enim accusante pristini illius sui iudici turpitudinem desperabat. ecce tibi consul, praetor, tribunus plebis nova novi generis edicta proponunt; ne reus adsit, ne citetur, ne quaeratur, ne mentionem omnino cuiquam iudicum aut iudiciorum facere liceat! quid ageret vir ad virtutem, dignitatem, gloriam natus vi sceleratorum hominum conroborata, legibus iudiciisque sublatis? cervices tribunus plebis privato, praestantissimus vir profligatissimo homini daret? an causam susceptam adfligeret? an se domi contineret? et vinci turpe putavit et deterreri ⟨et clam eripi: id egit⟩ ut, quoniam sibi in illum legibus uti non liceret, illius vim neque in suo neque in rei publicae periculo pertimesceret.
Edition notes (4)版本注记(4)
  • id eum umquam Lamb. in mg. 1581: id eũquam P1: id umquam P2rell.
  • adfligeret codd.: abiceret Ruhnken, Momms.
  • et clam eripi: id egit ut scripsi: etiam eripere eicit (elegit G) ut P1G: etiam eripi reeicit ut P2rell.: et latere (lamentari Hertz).
  • Perfecit ut Madv.: et clam se eripere ita ut Oehler: ita e re p. fecit ut (aut e re p. id egit ut) Richter: ⟨s⟩et amor r. p. perfecit ut Novak: et tegi ianua: manum emere et parare coepit ut Landgraf (cf. Vat. § 22; in Sen. § 4; ad Quir. § 14)
Source unit XML · 来源单元
urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi022.perseus-lat2:90
90quo modo igitur hoc in genere praesidi comparati accusas Sestium, cum idem laudes Milonem? an qui sua tecta defendit, qui ab aris focis ferrum flammamque depellit, qui sibi licere vult tuto esse in foro, in templo, in curia, iure praesidium comparat: qui vulneribus, quae cernit cotidie toto corpore, monetur ut aliquo praesidio caput et cervices et iugulum ac latera tutetur, hunc de vi accusandum putas?
Edition notes (1)版本注记(1)
  • praesid. compar. secl. Pluygers
Source unit XML · 来源单元
urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi022.perseus-lat2:91
91quis enim nostrum, iudices, ignorat ita naturam rerum tulisse ut quodam tempore homines nondum neque naturali neque civili iure descripto fusi per agros ac dispersi vagarentur, tantumque haberent quantum manu ac viribus per caedem ac vulnera aut eripere aut retinere potuissent? qui igitur primi virtute et consilio praestanti exstiterunt, ii perspecto genere humanae docilitatis atque ingeni dissupatos unum in locum congregarunt eosque ex feritate illa ad iustitiam atque ad mansuetudinem transduxerunt. tum res ad communem utilitatem, quas publicas appellamus, tum conventicula hominum, quae postea civitates nominatae sunt, tum domicilia coniuncta, quas urbis dicimus, invento et divino iure et humano moenibus saepserunt.
Edition notes (6)版本注记(6)
  • vestrum ks
  • dissup. P: dissip. Bk ed. R.
  • feritate HGk: ecferitate P: effer. B rell.
  • res communem utilitatem continentes Lamb.
  • post nominatae sunt suppl. instituerunt Madv.
  • ut moenibus Rau
Source unit XML · 来源单元
urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi022.perseus-lat2:92
92atque inter hanc vitam perpolitam humanitate et illam immanem nihil tam interest quam ius atque vis. Horum utro uti nolumus, altero est utendum. vim volumus exstingui, ius valeat necesse est, id est iudicia, quibus omne ius continetur; iudicia displicent aut nulla sunt, vis dominetur necesse est. hoc vident omnes: Milo et vidit et fecit, ut ius experiretur, vim depelleret. altero uti voluit, ut virtus audaciam vinceret; altero usus necessario est, ne virtus ab audacia vinceretur. eademque ratio fuit Sesti, si minus in accusando—neque enim per omnis fuit idem fieri necesse—at certe in necessitate defendendae salutis suae praesidioque contra vim et manum comparando.
Edition notes (2)版本注记(2)
  • volumus Hk: nolimus P rell. praeter s (nolumus)
  • ut ... depelleret secl. Pluygers
Source unit XML · 来源单元

Also in · 亦见: Cicero's orations · 西塞罗演说集 text · 原文

Editorial summary编辑摘要

At 86 Cicero praises Milo for trying law first and using protection when law and courts failed. At 87 he explicitly transfers the comparison to Sestius; 90 and 92 connect Sestius’ wounds and protection to that argument.第86节赞许米洛先求诸法律,而在法律与法庭失效时组织保护;第87节明言将米洛比于塞斯提乌斯,第90、92节把后者的创伤及护卫纳入论证。

After the selection选段之后

The speech now asks what hope remains for public service when the men Cicero calls destructive prosper. The verdict is known from Cicero’s letter (Q. fr. 2.4.1); neither the speech nor the letter records the jurors’ reasons.演说继而追问:被西塞罗视为败坏国家的人享有富贵,公共服务还能寄望于什么?判决见于西塞罗书信(Q. fr. 2.4.1);演说与书信都没有记载陪审者的理由。

Read the following original context阅读后文原文 (1)
urn:cts:latinLit:phi0474.phi022.perseus-lat2:93
93O di immortales! quemnam ostenditis exitum nobis? quam spem rei publicae datis? quotus quisque invenietur tanta virtute vir qui optimam quamque causam rei publicae amplectatur, qui bonis viris deserviat, qui solidam laudem veramque quaerat? cum sciat duo illa rei publicae paene fata, Gabinium et Pisonem, alterum haurire cotidie ex pacatissimis atque opulentissimis Syriae gazis innumerabile pondus auri, bellum inferre quiescentibus, ut eorum veteres inlibatasque divitias in profundissimum libidinum suarum gurgitem profundat, villam aedificare in oculis omnium tantam tugurium ut iam videatur esse illa villa quam ipse tribunus plebis pictam olim in contionibus explicabat, quo fortissimum ac summum civem in invidiam homo castus ac non cupidus vocaret;
Edition notes (4)版本注记(4)
  • amplectatur ... rei pub. om. ex homoeotel. P1: ad imam paginam suppl. P2
  • Gab. et Pis. secl. Pluygers
  • paratissimis C. Fr. Hermann: beatissimis Kiessling: optatissimis K. Busche: pacatissimae atque opulentissimae Hein., Hirschf.
  • quiescentibus quietis gentibus Weidner: gentibus Richter
Source unit XML · 来源单元

A preserved defence speech states the advocate’s case. It is neither a neutral record of the violence nor a judicial opinion.传世辩护辞记载辩方立论,既非暴力事件的中立记录,亦非法院判决书。

Edition, reuse and extraction版本、复用与提取

Perseus Digital Library, Tufts University; Cicero. M. Tulli Ciceronis Orationes, Vol. 5. Peterson, William, editor. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1909.

Perseus repository · 语料库 · CC BY-SA 4.0

Whitespace normalized; notes separated; deletions ⟦ ⟧ and additions/supplements ⟨ ⟩ marked; gaps explicit; no ancient wording supplied.

SHA-256 176b264d82f155372d5c8765f7e6a80c5d74aca1460a844e45086b9b77a3e17c

machine-assisted editorial synthesis; exact source extraction checked; independent scholarly review pending

Continue in the builds转入关联读本

A link to another build adds no evidence for the outcome.转往其他读本的链接不为此结局增加证据。